The Difference Between Reserves, Retained Earnings, and Provisions: Untangling the Confusion
The Difference Between Reserves, Retained Earnings, and Provisions: Untangling the Confusion
Are you confused between “Reserve” and “Provision”? You are not alone. While all three involve “setting money aside,” the accounting and legal reasons for each are completely different. In this article, we clear the confusion: What is the difference between Reserves, Retained Earnings, and Provisions? How does each affect your Profit and Loss? And when can you distribute these amounts to shareholders?
- Simple definitions: What is a Reserve? A Provision? Retained Earnings?
- Detailed comparison table (Accounting group, Purpose, Impact on profit).
- Why Provisions are considered “Expenses” while Reserves are “Appropriations.”
- A visual model (SVG) explaining the decision logic for setting money aside.
- The difference between Statutory Reserves and Voluntary Reserves.
- A practical numerical example showing where each appears on the Balance Sheet.
1) Defining the Three Terms
- Reserves: Portions of net profit set aside for specific purposes or general strengthening. It is an “Appropriation” of profit.
- Retained Earnings: The cumulative net income of the company since inception, minus all dividends paid.
- Provisions: Amounts charged against profit to cover a probable future liability or a decline in asset value. It is a “Charge” against profit.
2) Key Comparison Table
| Feature | Reserves | Retained Earnings | Provisions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accounting Group | Equity | Equity | Liabilities (or Asset Contra) |
| Source | Appropriation of Net Profit | Net Profit Surplus | Expense in P&L |
| Purpose | Future Strengthening | Reinvestment/Dividends | Covering Expected Losses |
| Impact on Profit | Doesn’t reduce Net Profit | Is the result of Net Profit | Reduces Net Profit |
| Distributable? | Only voluntary ones | Yes, most common source | No, never |
3) Reserves: Future Strengthening
Reserves are created after the Net Profit is calculated. They are divided into:
- Statutory (Legal) Reserves: Required by law (e.g., 10% of profit until it reaches 30% of capital).
- Voluntary Reserves: Created by management for expansion or to stabilize dividends.
4) Retained Earnings: Cumulative Success
This account acts as the “General Tank” for the company. At the end of every year, the net profit is transferred here. Management then decides: How much goes to Reserves? How much to Dividends? And the rest stays as Retained Earnings.
5) Provisions: Facing Probable Obligations
A provision is NOT a profit. It is a recognition of a liability that is likely to happen but its exact amount or timing is unknown.
FS Draft Workbook - Excel File
6) Decision Logic: Where does the profit go?
7) Impact on Profit vs. Equity
- Provisions: Decrease Net Income on the Income Statement and increase Liabilities on the Balance Sheet.
- Reserves/Retained Earnings: Only appear on the Balance Sheet (Equity) and the Statement of Changes in Equity.
8) Practical Numerical Example
Assume a company has Profit before Provisions of $100,000.
- It records a Provision for legal cases of $10,000.
➡ Net Profit becomes $90,000. - It appropriates 10% as Statutory Reserve ($9,000).
- It distributes $40,000 as Dividends.
- Result: Remaining $41,000 stays in Retained Earnings.
9) Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use reserves to pay for a lawsuit?
Technically, no. You should have a Provision for that. Reserves are used to strengthen the capital structure or cover final accounting losses.
Is “Allowance for Doubtful Accounts” a provision?
Yes, it is a provision against the asset (Receivables), reducing the asset’s net book value.
10) Conclusion
The summary is simple: Provisions are for facing the “Likely Bad News” before profit, while Reserves and Retained Earnings are for managing the “Good News” (Profit) after it happens. Understanding these differences ensures your financial statements provide a transparent and reliable picture for all stakeholders.