Digital Salla

IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts: Measurement Models and the CSM Explained

Standards & Financial Statements

IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts sets the principles for recognising, measuring, presenting and disclosing insurance contracts, so that an entity provides relevant information that faithfully represents them (IFRS 17.1). Its scope is defined by contract, not by type of entity: it applies to insurance contracts (including reinsurance contracts) that an entity issues, to reinsurance contracts it holds, and to investment contracts with discretionary participation features it issues, provided it also issues insurance contracts (IFRS 17.3). IFRS 17 replaced IFRS 4 and applies to annual reporting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2023 (IFRS 17.C1).

From IFRS 4 to IFRS 17

The International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) issued IFRS 4 in March 2004 as an interim Standard until it completed its insurance project, and IFRS 4 permitted a wide variety of accounting practices reflecting national requirements (IFRS Foundation). It exempted insurers from the IAS 8 criteria for developing accounting policies for insurance contracts (IFRS 4.13). It kept some safeguards, such as a liability adequacy test at the end of each reporting period (IFRS 4.15), and let existing practices continue, such as measuring insurance liabilities on an undiscounted basis (IFRS 4.25).

In May 2017 the IASB completed the project by issuing IFRS 17, which replaces IFRS 4. The main shifts:

AreaIFRS 4IFRS 17
Accounting policiesExisting policies could continue, outside the IAS 8 criteria (IFRS 4.13)One measurement model with defined variants (IFRS 17.29)
DiscountingUndiscounted liabilities could continue (IFRS 4.25)Current discount rates required for the fulfilment cash flows (IFRS 17.36)
ProfitDepended on the policies applied (IFRS 4.13)Unearned profit (the CSM) recognised as services are provided; losses on onerous contracts recognised at once (IFRS 17.38, 47)

Scope: which contracts?

An insurance contract is a contract under which one party (the issuer) accepts significant insurance risk from another party (the policyholder) by agreeing to compensate the policyholder if a specified uncertain future event (the insured event) adversely affects the policyholder (IFRS 17, Appendix A).

Among the items the Standard excludes (IFRS 17.7):

  • warranties provided by a manufacturer, dealer or retailer in connection with a sale;
  • employers' assets and liabilities from employee benefit plans;
  • financial guarantee contracts, unless the issuer has previously asserted explicitly that it regards them as insurance contracts and has used insurance contract accounting for them, in which case it chooses, contract by contract, between IFRS 17 and the financial instruments Standards;
  • contingent consideration in a business combination; and
  • insurance contracts in which the entity is the policyholder, other than reinsurance contracts held.

Two options matter in practice. Fixed-fee service contracts that meet specified conditions may be accounted for under IFRS 15 instead (IFRS 17.8). Contracts such as loans with death waivers, whose compensation is limited to settling the policyholder's obligation, go under IFRS 17 or IFRS 9 by an irrevocable choice for each portfolio (IFRS 17.8A).

Reinsurance contracts held and investment contracts with discretionary participation features use the same model with modifications (IFRS 17.29).

Level of aggregation

IFRS 17 measures groups of contracts, not single policies:

  1. Portfolio: contracts subject to similar risks and managed together (IFRS 17.14).
  2. Groups: each portfolio of contracts issued is divided into at least three groups: contracts onerous at initial recognition, contracts that at initial recognition have no significant possibility of becoming onerous subsequently, and the remaining contracts (IFRS 17.16).
  3. Cohorts: contracts issued more than one year apart cannot be in the same group (IFRS 17.22), which is why practice speaks of "annual cohorts".

Groups are established at initial recognition and their composition is not reassessed (IFRS 17.24). A group is recognised from the earliest of: the beginning of its coverage period; the date the first payment from a policyholder becomes due; and, for an onerous group, when it becomes onerous (IFRS 17.25).

The general measurement model

On initial recognition, a group is measured at the total of the fulfilment cash flows and the contractual service margin (CSM) (IFRS 17.32).

Fulfilment cash flows

  • Estimates of future cash flows within the contract boundary: an unbiased, probability-weighted mean of the full range of possible outcomes, using reasonable and supportable information available without undue cost or effort (IFRS 17.33).
  • Discounting at rates that reflect the time value of money, the characteristics of the cash flows and the liquidity characteristics of the contracts, consistent with observable current market prices (IFRS 17.36).
  • A risk adjustment for non-financial risk: the compensation the entity requires for bearing uncertainty about the amount and timing of cash flows that arises from non-financial risk (IFRS 17.37).

The CSM

The CSM represents the unearned profit the entity will recognise as it provides insurance contract services. It is measured so that initial recognition produces no income or expenses (IFRS 17.38). If the fulfilment cash flows and other cash flows at initial recognition are a net outflow, the contract is onerous: the entity recognises the loss in profit or loss at once, and the group's CSM is zero (IFRS 17.47).

Subsequent measurement

At each reporting date a group's carrying amount comprises the liability for remaining coverage (LRC), which is the fulfilment cash flows for future service plus the CSM, and the liability for incurred claims (LIC), which is the fulfilment cash flows for past service (IFRS 17.40). For contracts without direct participation features, the CSM is rolled forward for (IFRS 17.44):

  1. new contracts added to the group;
  2. interest accreted at the discount rates determined at initial recognition (IFRS 17.B72(b));
  3. changes in fulfilment cash flows that relate to future service;
  4. currency exchange differences; and
  5. the amount recognised as insurance revenue for the services provided in the period.

The release uses coverage units, which reflect the quantity of benefits and the expected coverage period of each contract. The CSM at the end of the period is allocated equally to each coverage unit provided in the period and expected in the future (IFRS 17.B119). If unfavourable changes relating to future service exceed the CSM, the excess is a loss in profit or loss (IFRS 17.48), tracked through a loss component of the LRC (IFRS 17.49).

Illustrative example: how the CSM works

Illustrative figures only, under these assumptions:

  • A group of three-year contracts is issued at the start of Year 1, and a single premium of 900 is received at initial recognition.
  • Expected claims are 200 at the end of each year (600 in total), and claims occur exactly as expected.
  • The risk adjustment is 120 at initial recognition and is released evenly (40 a year).
  • Each year provides the same number of coverage units.
  • Discounting is ignored to keep the arithmetic simple; in practice cash flows are discounted (IFRS 17.36) and interest is accreted on the CSM (IFRS 17.44(b)).
  • There are no insurance acquisition cash flows and no investment component.

Initial recognition. The fulfilment cash flows are 720 (600 + 120) against a premium of 900 received at that date. The CSM of 180 absorbs the difference, so no gain is recognised on day one (IFRS 17.38), and the LRC is 900 (720 + 180).

Year 1, as expected:

ItemAmount
Expected claims for the year200
Risk adjustment released40
CSM recognised (180 ÷ 3 coverage units)60
Insurance revenue300
Insurance service expenses (claims incurred)(200)
Insurance service result100

Insurance revenue for a period can be analysed as the expected service expenses, the change in the risk adjustment, the CSM recognised and other amounts, if any (IFRS 17.B124). At the end of Year 1 the LRC is 600 (fulfilment cash flows 480 + CSM 120), which equals 900 − 300. Over the three years revenue totals 900, the premium received, because there is neither a financing effect nor an investment component (IFRS 17.B120).

Variant 1: a change in estimate. Suppose that at the end of Year 1 expected claims for Years 2 and 3 rise to 215 each (+30 in total), with the risk adjustment unchanged. The increase relates to future service, so it reduces the CSM rather than profit: 180 − 30 = 150 (IFRS 17.44(c)). Spread over the three coverage units, 50 is recognised in Year 1 and 100 is carried forward (IFRS 17.44(e)). Year 1 revenue becomes 290 (200 + 40 + 50), and Years 2 and 3 each show 305 (215 + 40 + 50), still 900 in total.

Variant 2: onerous contracts. Had the increase been 210 instead (claims of 305 in each remaining year), it would exceed the CSM of 180. The CSM would fall to zero and the excess of 30 would be recognised as a loss at once (IFRS 17.48). Likewise, if the fulfilment cash flows had exceeded the premium at initial recognition, the group would have been onerous from day one, with an immediate loss and no CSM (IFRS 17.47).

The premium allocation approach (PAA)

An entity may use this simplified approach for a group if, and only if, at inception (IFRS 17.53):

  • it reasonably expects the result would not differ materially from the LRC measured under the general model; or
  • the coverage period of each contract in the group is one year or less.

The first test is not met if, at inception, the entity expects significant variability in the fulfilment cash flows before a claim is incurred. Variability increases, for example, with embedded derivatives and with the length of the coverage period (IFRS 17.54).

Under the PAA, the LRC starts at the premiums received less any insurance acquisition cash flows, and is reduced as insurance revenue is recognised for services provided (IFRS 17.55). The simplifications:

  • acquisition cash flows may be expensed when incurred if each contract's coverage period is no more than one year (IFRS 17.59(a));
  • the LRC need not be adjusted for the time value of money if the time between providing each part of the services and the related premium due date is no more than a year (IFRS 17.56); and
  • incurred claims are still measured at fulfilment cash flows, but need not be discounted if they are expected to be paid within one year of being incurred (IFRS 17.59(b)).

The variable fee approach (VFA)

Insurance contracts with direct participation features meet three conditions: the contractual terms specify that the policyholder participates in a share of a clearly identified pool of underlying items; the entity expects to pay an amount equal to a substantial share of the fair value returns on those items; and it expects a substantial proportion of any change in the amounts paid to vary with the change in the fair value of those items (IFRS 17.B101). For these contracts, the CSM is also adjusted for changes in the entity's share of the fair value of the underlying items (IFRS 17.45). The approach does not apply to reinsurance contracts held (IFRS 17.29(b)).

Presentation

  • Statement of financial position: portfolios of insurance contracts issued and of reinsurance contracts held are presented separately, split between those that are assets and those that are liabilities (IFRS 17.78).
  • Statement of financial performance: amounts are split into an insurance service result (insurance revenue and insurance service expenses) and insurance finance income or expenses (IFRS 17.80).
  • Insurance revenue depicts the services provided at the consideration the entity expects in exchange (IFRS 17.83). Revenue and service expenses exclude investment components, and premium information inconsistent with that principle is not presented in profit or loss (IFRS 17.85).
  • Insurance service expenses comprise incurred claims (excluding repayments of investment components), other incurred insurance service expenses and other specified amounts (IFRS 17.84).
  • Insurance finance income or expenses reflect the time value of money, financial risk and changes in them (IFRS 17.87). The entity chooses between including them all in profit or loss and disaggregating them between profit or loss and other comprehensive income (IFRS 17.88).

Transition

The date of initial application is the start of the annual period in which IFRS 17 is first applied; the transition date is the start of the annual period immediately before it (IFRS 17.C2). The Standard applies retrospectively unless that is impracticable or a limited exception applies (IFRS 17.C3). For a group where retrospective application is impracticable, the entity uses either (IFRS 17.C5):

  • the modified retrospective approach, which seeks the closest outcome to retrospective application using reasonable and supportable information; without such information, the fair value approach applies (IFRS 17.C6); or
  • the fair value approach, under which the CSM or loss component at the transition date is the difference between the group's fair value and its fulfilment cash flows. That fair value is measured without applying paragraph 47 of IFRS 13 on demand features (IFRS 17.C20).

An entity that first applies IFRS 17 and IFRS 9 at the same time may use a "classification overlay" when presenting comparative information about a financial asset if that information has not been restated for IFRS 9 (IFRS 17.C28A).

What has changed, and current status

  • Issue and effective date. IFRS 17 was issued in May 2017. In June 2020 the IASB amended it to help companies implement the Standard and explain their financial performance, and IFRS 17 as amended is effective for annual reporting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2023 (IFRS Foundation). Earlier application was permitted for entities applying IFRS 9 on or before the date of initial application of IFRS 17 (IFRS 17.C1).
  • Comparative information. In December 2021 the IASB issued Initial Application of IFRS 17 and IFRS 9—Comparative Information, a transition option for comparative information about financial assets (IFRS Foundation).
  • IFRS 4 and IFRS 9. A September 2016 amendment to IFRS 4 addressed the consequences of applying IFRS 9 before IFRS 17 (IFRS Foundation). IFRS 4, as last amended, gave insurers meeting its criteria a temporary exemption from IFRS 9 for annual periods beginning before 1 January 2023 (IFRS 4.20A).
  • IFRS 18 and IFRS 19. IFRS 18 Presentation and Disclosure in Financial Statements (issued April 2024) and IFRS 19 Subsidiaries without Public Accountability: Disclosures (issued May 2024) made consequential amendments to IFRS 17 that apply for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2027 (IFRS Foundation: changes in the 2026 edition).

Related Standards and a practical tool

Sources

Blog

A tool for this topic

Apply what you read with a ready file

Full IFRS

Full IFRS Bundle

Four related products for one price below the sum of their individual prices; every file is delivered on payment.

View bundle